Structuring the humanist community. Or not.

There was a bit of a fuss on twitter today (19 October) about the kind of organizational structure that the humanist community should have ....

There was a bit of a fuss on twitter today (19 October) about the kind of organizational structure that the humanist community should have.  Unfortunately I was teaching and so missed it, but I did catch a few of the later tweets.  I'll pitch out a few thoughts of my own, coming from a design background.

The basic argument seemed to involve not so much what structure one should expect for a functional humanist community, but rather whether there should be a structure at all.  This part of the discussion is well summarized by Leah Libresco.  PZ Myers tweeted and blogged about it a lot.  He was rather vocal, if I read him correctly, that no structure based on a hierarchy of positions that provide its holders with power is acceptable.  This a-structural approach flies in the face, as PZ himself notes, of religious hierarchies, but also of pretty much every other social organization - government, business, NGOs,....

There's two thoughts that come to mind.

Thought #1.

This one is rather obvious.  The real conversation is about institutionalizing positions in a hierarchy, and not whether any one person should "lead" any particular activity for any length of time.  What I suggest is that PZ is right on this point - if the humanist community is to learn from the mistakes of the past, it should seek are structures that do not institutionalize power.

I think Leah may have one very good idea in her references to the scientific community, in that leadership in science is generally based on merit, which in turn is based on performance, and that the positions themselves are fluid, responding to the needs of the moment, rather than being fixed by fiat based on the intentions of some relatively arbitrary group of "founders."  The structure needed, in this view, is not a structure of positions and power, but rather one of process.  That is, what's needed here is a process structure that defines how issues are identified, how temporary/local leadership is allocated, how projects start and end to address those issues, and how to rank the merit of individuals based on their records.  Such a system could be entirely fluid, yet support sufficient structure for any specific purpose to keep things organized.

My second thought is that some of the friction that occurred in the twitter discussion exists because there is an underlying, tacit disagreement on why a structure is needed.

This is where I get design-y.  You don't design something if you don't know what it's for.  Clearly, from the discussion - even just the teeny bit of it that I saw on twitter - it is evident to me that not enough discussion has been had about the purpose(s) an organizational structure would serve.  Too many things have been designed without purpose (my favorite example is the Apple Lisa).  Considering how much is at stake in defining any kind of structure for humanist communities, it rather behooves us to try to get it right the first time.

So I'd suggest that some effort should be expended to define, as crisply as possible, why some kind of structure is needed for humanist communities.  There's ways to do this.  I happen to know about those ways.  And though I may regret doing this, I would be happy to help with such an exercise, if there's enough interest.

Final thought: I find this whole discussion very interesting in that it is, as far as I can tell, something new and suggestive of a positive change in the humanist/atheist community.  Yay team!

COMMENTS

Name

academia activism admin aesthetics affect ageing AI analogy android anthropology anticipation app architecture art arts Asia assistive technology balance biology biomimetics book branding building business CAD Canada case cfp change revision children codesign cognition collaboration colonization commercialization commonplacing communication design competition complexity computation computer science computing concept map conference constructivism conversational analysis craft creative arts creativity CSCW culture cybernetics design design thinking digital digital media digital reproduction digital scholarship disability dissertation drawing economics education effectiveness efficiency emotion engineering environment ergonomics ethics ethnography Evernote evolution exhibition exoskeleton experience experimental studies fail fashion featured food function modeling futurism gender studies Germany globalization grantsmanship graphic design Greece HCI health heritage history housing human factors humanism identity image inclusivity industrial design informatics information innovation interaction interior design internet of things iphone journal journalism language law library life life cycle lifehack logistics luxury making management manufacturing material culture materials mechanics media method migration mobile motion design movie new product development Nexus 6 olfaction online organization packaging paper participatory design PBL pengate performance PhD philosophy planning policy politics practice predatory preservation prison proceedings productivity project management public space publishing reading Remember The Milk reproduction research resource-limited design review Samsung scholarship science science fiction semiotics senses service design simplicity society sociology software space strategic design student sustainability systems tactile tangibility technology textile theatre theory Toodledo Toronto tourism traffic transhumanism transnationalism transportation tv uncertainty universal design urban usa usability user experience visualization wearable well-being women workshop writing
false
ltr
item
The Trouble with Normal...: Structuring the humanist community. Or not.
Structuring the humanist community. Or not.
The Trouble with Normal...
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/2011/10/structuring-humanist-community-or-not.html
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/2011/10/structuring-humanist-community-or-not.html
true
389378225362699292
UTF-8
Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy