The twisted logic of American catholics

Adam Lee recently posted a great article at Big Think, The Chasm of the Middle Ground , that considers the bigotry that seems to be the curr...

Adam Lee recently posted a great article at Big Think, The Chasm of the Middle Ground, that considers the bigotry that seems to be the current fad in American religious fundamentalism.  I just want to comment on one passage from Adam's post (I've emphasized key parts).
We saw this in the fights over the American health-care bill, where Roman Catholic bishops asserted that any employer - not just a church employer, but any employer, even the manager of a Taco Bell - should be able to deny his employees insurance coverage for any medical procedure to which he objects on religious grounds. Since most major medical procedures are ruinously expensive if not covered by insurance, this is equivalent to saying that employers should be able to dictate their workers' access to medical care. In the same vein, when there was a rash of teenagers committing suicide after vicious homophobic bullying, evangelicals in the Anoka-Hennepin School District vehemently objected to a proposed anti-bullying policy, claiming that it was an unconstitutional restriction on their religious freedom. Evangelical spokespeople have also explicitly endorsed this logic, that "if gays are not the ones being discriminated against, then Christians will be".
The first instance alone may warrant several long essays to explain fully the utterly twisted logic being employed by the religulous.  Here's just an abbreviated list of some of the problems:

  • That an employer has a moral obligation to police the morality of his/her employees in their personal lives as well as their work.  This is clearly just a case of the catholic church seeking to subvert labour relations into being its weapon, by promising the employer afterlife brownie points.
  • That the employer is morally responsible for decisions made by the employee regarding the employee's own health just because the employer is paying for the health services rendered. This is playing the "guilt card" - something at which catholics are experts - to coerce employers fearful for their immortal souls into removing from others a fundamental freedom of choice.
  • That religion has any role to play at all in labour relations.  Morality, whether set by religious dogma (bad) or rational and philosophical considerations (good), stands apart from labour relations.  Morality is codified in documents that identify the principles for which a nation stands, documents which inform the legal system, which in turn sets bounds on labour relations to (presumably) ensure the well-being of the citizenry.  Morality is so far removed from labour relations, it's rather like saying your doctor will prescribe medicine based on quantum mechanics.
  • That insurance coverage can be predicated on religious grounds. This is just pathetic, and a sure sign one's nation is heading down a similar road taken by islamic theocracies.  And look what it got them!
The second instance is a classic case of both category error and false dichotomy.

The category error involves lumping all christians into the group of sanctimonious pricks who think its discriminatory to stop them from discriminating against LBGT folk.  There are many christians who have no problem with LBGT rights.  That mainstream christians aren't far more vocal against the fundiots in their midst bothers me tremendously, but their silence (though harmful in itself) is at least no where near the vile hatefulness of the truly religulous.  Beyond the fetid stink of the rants of the fundiots, moderate christians should be properly incensed by the fundiots speaking on their behalf.

The false dichotomy (that either gays are discriminated against, or christians are) ignores at least one possible alternative: that neither gays nor christians will be discriminated against.  There is no reason to exclude this alternative a-priori... unless, of course, one grants the (factually incorrect) categorization that all christians are anti-gay.

It's all childishness.  Stupid, hateful, school-yard homophobia borne of a church that was never interested in well-being but really only in power and control.  I really don't care if the religulous want to persist in their ignorant irrationality.  But that their crude philistinism is granted equal standing to rational, evidence-based positions that promote true equality and well-being sickens me as little else can.

COMMENTS

Name

academia activism adaptation admin aesthetics affect ageing AI analogy android anthropology anticipation app architecture art arts Asia assistive technology automobile balance biology biomimetics book branding building built environment business CAD Canada care case cfp change revision children codesign cognition collaboration colonization commercialization commonplacing communication design competition complexity computation computer science computing concept map conference constructivism conversational analysis craft creative arts creativity CSCW culture cybernetics degrowth dementia design design thinking digital digital media digital reproduction digital scholarship disability dissertation drawing economics education effectiveness efficiency emotion engineering environment ergonomics ethics ethnography Evernote evolution exhibition exoskeleton experience experimental studies fail fashion featured film food function modeling futurism gender studies Germany globalization grantsmanship graphic design Greece HCI health heritage history housing human factors humanism identity image inclusivity industrial design informatics information innovation interaction interdisciplinarity interior design internet of things intervention iphone journal journalism language law library life life cycle lifehack literature review logistics luxury making management manufacturing material culture materials mechanics media method migration mobile motion design movie nature new product development Nexus 6 olfaction online open design organization packaging paper participatory design PBL pengate performance PhD philosophy planning policy politics practice predatory preservation prison proceedings productivity project management public space publishing reading Remember The Milk reproduction research resource-limited design reuse review Samsung scholarship science science fiction semiotics senses service design simplicity society sociology software space strategic design student sustainability systems tactile tangibility technology textile theatre theory Toodledo Toronto tourism traffic transhumanism transnationalism transportation tv uncertainty universal design urban usa usability user experience visualization wearable well-being women workshop writing
false
ltr
item
The Trouble with Normal...: The twisted logic of American catholics
The twisted logic of American catholics
The Trouble with Normal...
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/2012/07/the-twisted-logic-of-american-catholics.html
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/
http://filsalustri.blogspot.com/2012/07/the-twisted-logic-of-american-catholics.html
true
389378225362699292
UTF-8
Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS CONTENT IS PREMIUM Please share to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy