Are atheist immigrants unwelcome in the USA?

Chris Johnson's 64-year old stepmother applied for her US citizenship after 30 years of residency, but refused to "take up arms in ...

Chris Johnson's 64-year old stepmother applied for her US citizenship after 30 years of residency, but refused to "take up arms in defense of the United States" on moral grounds.  It turns out she's an atheist, so she could not object conscientiously on religious grounds.  Yet those are the only grounds that the pencil-pushers in the US government would allow.  (Details here.)  The FFRF has weighed in on the matter, and makes a compelling case for allowing her application.

I think some comments are in order.

First, of all - Bravo! to the woman who stood up for what is right.  The US would clearly be better off with more citizens like her, than with people like Rick Perry, Charles Manson, and Paris Hilton (i.e., useless wastes of life).

Next, there are some perfectly reasonable people about who have argued that she should have just checked the box, no matter what she believed.  I can respect that perspective, but I also worry about it.  I cannot speak to the woman's actual motivation for refusing to "check the box," but personally, I find it troubling.  If one really respects the nation one tries to join and the institutions of that nation - which are in many ways its most direct manifestations - then one really needs to answer truthfully. Getting citizenship is A Big Dealtm and being less than honest can place one on a slippery slope.  If one finds it possible to essentially lie on one's citizenship application, then how much easier will one find it to lie on other matters?  Multiply this effect across all immigrants to a nation, and one could see, over time, how that nation's citizenry could become polluted with liars.

Others have suggested that the real problem is the anachronistic phrasing of the requirements. Must one really "take up arms" in the sense of using weapons, or is it a matter of defending one's nation, adopted or otherwise, to the best of one's abilities?  I would like to think that the former is the more enlightened interpretation.  However, so long as statements require interpretation, there is the chance of misinterpretation, which would likely create more problems than it could possibly solve.  So perhaps it's time that Americans stopped dwelling on the actual words used and focused more on the ideas behind them.  Of course, that would require a kind of reflective intelligence and rationality that seems sorely lacking in some quarters (...cough - GOP - cough...).

Finally, it seems to me that there's a question of context.  What do Americans really aspire to these days?  Surely, the principles remain, but their implementation in practice and in law must adapt to modern times.  It strikes me that one of the reasons that so much manufacturing has moved to Asia that used to be done in the US is partly a function of the expectations of Americans.  Cannot they see that some of the problems they now face are obviously a result of actions that they themselves took, regardless of intention?  Cannot they learn from their mistakes?

In closing, I would suggest to Mr. Johnson's stepmother that, if things don't work out in the US, she should consider Canada.  We're much more flexible here. :-)



academia,13,activism,1,adaptation,1,admin,12,aesthetics,3,affect,1,ageing,1,AI,2,analogy,2,android,1,animation,1,anthropology,3,anticipation,1,app,1,architecture,19,art,1,arts,44,Asia,2,assistive technology,2,automobile,1,balance,28,biology,3,biomimetics,12,book,7,branding,4,building,3,built environment,1,business,5,CAD,2,Canada,29,care,1,case,11,cfp,376,change revision,1,children,1,Circa,1,codesign,3,cognition,6,collaboration,3,colonization,1,commercialization,3,commonplacing,1,communication design,9,competition,4,complexity,3,computation,14,computer science,1,computing,13,concept map,3,conference,176,constructivism,1,conversational analysis,1,craft,5,creative arts,1,creativity,8,CSCW,1,culture,14,cybernetics,2,degrowth,1,dementia,1,design,108,design thinking,7,digital,3,digital media,4,digital reproduction,1,digital scholarship,1,disability,3,dissertation,1,drawing,3,economics,19,education,41,effectiveness,14,efficiency,12,emotion,1,engineering,31,environment,14,ergonomics,1,ethics,49,ethnography,1,Evernote,1,evolution,4,exhibition,3,exoskeleton,1,experience,3,experimental studies,3,fail,1,fashion,8,featured,9,film,1,food,4,function modeling,1,futurism,9,gender studies,2,geography,1,Germany,1,globalization,3,grantsmanship,1,graphic design,20,Greece,1,HCI,37,health,12,heritage,2,history,18,Hobonichi,1,housing,2,human factors,3,humanism,56,identity,1,illustration,1,image,2,inclusivity,2,industrial design,2,informatics,3,information,5,innovation,12,interaction,21,interdisciplinarity,2,interior design,5,internet of things,3,intervention,1,iphone,16,journal,92,journalism,1,language,4,law,1,library,1,life,99,life cycle,2,lifehack,10,literature,1,literature review,1,logistics,2,luxury,1,making,4,management,9,manufacturing,4,material culture,4,materials,4,mechanics,1,media,9,method,45,migration,1,mobile,1,motion design,1,movie,2,multimedia,1,nature,1,new product development,5,Nexus 6,1,olfaction,1,online,1,open design,1,organization,1,packaging,1,paper,17,participatory design,9,PBL,1,pengate,1,performance,1,PhD,24,philosophy,44,planning,3,policy,6,politics,44,practice,13,predatory,3,preservation,2,prison,1,proceedings,1,productivity,103,project management,1,public space,6,publishing,3,reading,1,Remember The Milk,1,reproduction,1,research,82,research through design,1,resource-limited design,1,reuse,1,review,72,Samsung,3,scholarship,43,science,46,science fiction,3,semiotics,4,senses,1,service design,12,simplicity,5,society,106,sociology,5,software,61,space,4,strategic design,2,student,8,sustainability,40,systems,49,tactile,1,tangibility,1,technology,16,textile,2,theatre,3,theory,6,Toodledo,2,Toronto,2,tourism,1,traffic,1,transhumanism,1,transnationalism,1,transportation,3,tv,1,uncertainty,1,universal design,3,urban,11,usa,8,usability,1,user experience,3,visualization,14,wearable,3,well-being,6,women,1,workshop,52,writing,2,
The Trouble with Normal...: Are atheist immigrants unwelcome in the USA?
Are atheist immigrants unwelcome in the USA?
The Trouble with Normal...
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share. STEP 2: Click the link you shared to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy