|FEATURES$type=ticker$count=12$cols=4$cate=0

The trouble with marketing

Influencing choice can be bad. I came across an old link I'd squirrelled  away about research on consumers' mindsets.  I found t...

Influencing choice can be bad.
I came across an old link I'd squirrelled  away about research on consumers' mindsets.  I found the way the research was written up for public consumption to demonstrate quite crisply the ethical difference between design and marketing.

In a blurb in MITSloan Management Review from October 2010, we have a research summary by Kelly Goldsmith, Jing Xu and Ravi Dhar, called The Power of Customers’ Mindset.  It reports on research suggesting that there are two different consumer mindsets that result on different approaches to deciding what to buy.  Some people have an abstract mindset; these are people who will tend to notice similarities between various products based on abstract characteristics and attributes. And then there are people with a concrete mindset; these are people who will tend to notice differences in particular characteristics and attributes of different products.

So far, so good. This doesn't surprise me at all.  It's rather like so many other dichotomies that researchers seem to find in people.

But then we have this: "In other words, if you get a consumer thinking a certain way, that way of thinking — that mindset — can influence his or her subsequent shopping behavior."  And the research then goes on to suggest that "...an abstract mindset increases the number of products consumers select."

It seems quite clear, then, that the point of the research is to help marketers influence people's minds.  To make them want things.  Of course, the marketers are in a pretty serious conflict of interest: they benefit directly from ensuring their campaigns are successful, whether or not people actually want or need the products they market.

This research is also useful for designers, but in an antithetical sense to that implied by the report from the Sloan Review.  In design, we do not (necessarily) seek to change the minds of people.  We seek to understand them and help them achieve their goals.  If we can unequivocally demonstrate that their goals are harmful, then a designer should make every attempt to exert influence, but only by using evidence-based, sound reasoning.

Whereas the designer seeks to help people fulfil their goals through design, the marketer seeks to manipulate people's goals to the benefit of their client, whose ethics are rarely if ever verified by the marketer before a contract is signed.

I should note that the Sloan Review blurb mentions a working paper covering the actual research done in greater detail.  I cannot find any evidence of that working paper.  I did find mention, however, in the vita of the lead author (available at her home institution's website), of a working paper on the same general topic and by the same three authors.  The paper itself, though, eludes me entirely.

COMMENTS

Name

academia,12,activism,1,adaptation,1,admin,12,aesthetics,3,affect,1,ageing,1,AI,2,analogy,2,android,1,animation,1,anthropology,3,anticipation,1,app,1,architecture,18,art,1,arts,44,Asia,2,assistive technology,2,automobile,1,balance,28,biology,3,biomimetics,12,book,7,branding,3,building,3,built environment,1,business,5,CAD,2,Canada,29,care,1,case,11,cfp,363,change revision,1,children,1,Circa,1,codesign,3,cognition,6,collaboration,3,colonization,1,commercialization,3,commonplacing,1,communication design,8,competition,4,complexity,3,computation,14,computer science,1,computing,13,concept map,3,conference,166,constructivism,1,conversational analysis,1,craft,5,creative arts,1,creativity,8,CSCW,1,culture,13,cybernetics,2,degrowth,1,dementia,1,design,108,design thinking,7,digital,3,digital media,3,digital reproduction,1,digital scholarship,1,disability,3,dissertation,1,drawing,3,economics,19,education,41,effectiveness,14,efficiency,12,emotion,1,engineering,30,environment,14,ergonomics,1,ethics,49,ethnography,1,Evernote,1,evolution,4,exhibition,3,exoskeleton,1,experience,3,experimental studies,3,fail,1,fashion,7,featured,9,film,1,food,4,function modeling,1,futurism,9,gender studies,1,Germany,1,globalization,3,grantsmanship,1,graphic design,20,Greece,1,HCI,35,health,11,heritage,2,history,18,Hobonichi,1,housing,2,human factors,3,humanism,56,identity,1,illustration,1,image,2,inclusivity,2,industrial design,2,informatics,3,information,5,innovation,12,interaction,21,interdisciplinarity,2,interior design,4,internet of things,3,intervention,1,iphone,16,journal,90,journalism,1,language,4,law,1,library,1,life,99,life cycle,2,lifehack,10,literature,1,literature review,1,logistics,2,luxury,1,making,4,management,9,manufacturing,4,material culture,4,materials,4,mechanics,1,media,9,method,45,migration,1,mobile,1,motion design,1,movie,2,multimedia,1,nature,1,new product development,5,Nexus 6,1,olfaction,1,online,1,open design,1,organization,1,packaging,1,paper,17,participatory design,9,PBL,1,pengate,1,performance,1,PhD,24,philosophy,44,planning,2,policy,6,politics,44,practice,13,predatory,3,preservation,2,prison,1,proceedings,1,productivity,103,project management,1,public space,6,publishing,3,reading,1,Remember The Milk,1,reproduction,1,research,80,resource-limited design,1,reuse,1,review,72,Samsung,3,scholarship,43,science,46,science fiction,3,semiotics,4,senses,1,service design,12,simplicity,5,society,106,sociology,4,software,61,space,3,strategic design,2,student,8,sustainability,39,systems,48,tactile,1,tangibility,1,technology,16,textile,2,theatre,3,theory,6,Toodledo,2,Toronto,2,tourism,1,traffic,1,transhumanism,1,transnationalism,1,transportation,3,tv,1,uncertainty,1,universal design,3,urban,10,usa,8,usability,1,user experience,3,visualization,14,wearable,3,well-being,6,women,1,workshop,51,writing,2,
ltr
item
The Trouble with Normal...: The trouble with marketing
The trouble with marketing
http://media.economist.com/images/images-magazine/2010/12/18/xl/20101218_xlp006.jpg
The Trouble with Normal...
https://filsalustri.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-trouble-with-marketing.html
https://filsalustri.blogspot.com/
https://filsalustri.blogspot.com/
https://filsalustri.blogspot.com/2014/06/the-trouble-with-marketing.html
true
389378225362699292
UTF-8
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share. STEP 2: Click the link you shared to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy