Defining terms together: another data point

I’ve often argued that related terms need to be defined together to ensure consistency and completeness of coverage of a domain.  I’ve bee...

I’ve often argued that related terms need to be defined together to ensure consistency and completeness of coverage of a domain.  I’ve been particularly adamant about defining knowledge, belief, and faith as a triplet of terms; likewise for function, behaviour, and structure.  I’ve found another doublet of terms to which this rule applies, albeit it’s in a specific research context.

Yesterday, I met with a colleague and one of his PhD students. The student is working on developing ways of accurately measuring organizational performance such that both issues of quality and ergonomics are considered.  The background is simple: historically, both ergonomics and quality of production have mattered, but they’ve been treated as disjoint and uncoupled features of organizations.  In truth, they are tightly coupled because good human factors helps increase quality.

The student was using two terms, metric and indicator, together - often in the same sentence - but didn’t seem to be able to communicate the distinction between them very well.  I'm sure he knew what he meant, but he seemed to have some difficulty getting the right words out.  If he talked about what one term meant, he did so without mentioning any relationships the one had to or with the other.

I suggested that he should define them together, and with respect to concepts that were more fundamental than either of the terms themselves.  Clearly, in his work, the terms were particularly meaningful in how they identified different features of the situations he was analyzing.  To make sure that (a) the domain of interest was completely covered by the two terms, yet (b) there was no conceptual overlap (and therefore ambiguity) between them, they needed to be defined together.

To do this, I offered an analogy to a dial gauge.  The indicator is like a particular reading - the “needle,” if you will, of the gauge, while the metric is the dial against which the needle moves - the scale, the range of values, the units….  This seemed to go over quite well.  Given this crisp distinction, he ought to be able to make very clear statements about various data, facts, and observations in his research, and not ever confuse what the indicator is, and what the metric is. I knew I was onto something because he lit up and told me that was exactly how he thought of the terms.

This lends support, I think, to the notion of defining groups of terms together.



academia,12,activism,1,adaptation,1,admin,12,aesthetics,3,affect,1,ageing,1,AI,2,analogy,2,android,1,animation,1,anthropology,3,anticipation,1,app,1,architecture,18,art,1,arts,44,Asia,2,assistive technology,2,automobile,1,balance,28,biology,3,biomimetics,12,book,7,branding,3,building,3,built environment,1,business,5,CAD,2,Canada,29,care,1,case,11,cfp,365,change revision,1,children,1,Circa,1,codesign,3,cognition,6,collaboration,3,colonization,1,commercialization,3,commonplacing,1,communication design,8,competition,4,complexity,3,computation,14,computer science,1,computing,13,concept map,3,conference,168,constructivism,1,conversational analysis,1,craft,5,creative arts,1,creativity,8,CSCW,1,culture,13,cybernetics,2,degrowth,1,dementia,1,design,108,design thinking,7,digital,3,digital media,3,digital reproduction,1,digital scholarship,1,disability,3,dissertation,1,drawing,3,economics,19,education,41,effectiveness,14,efficiency,12,emotion,1,engineering,30,environment,14,ergonomics,1,ethics,49,ethnography,1,Evernote,1,evolution,4,exhibition,3,exoskeleton,1,experience,3,experimental studies,3,fail,1,fashion,7,featured,9,film,1,food,4,function modeling,1,futurism,9,gender studies,1,Germany,1,globalization,3,grantsmanship,1,graphic design,20,Greece,1,HCI,35,health,12,heritage,2,history,18,Hobonichi,1,housing,2,human factors,3,humanism,56,identity,1,illustration,1,image,2,inclusivity,2,industrial design,2,informatics,3,information,5,innovation,12,interaction,21,interdisciplinarity,2,interior design,4,internet of things,3,intervention,1,iphone,16,journal,90,journalism,1,language,4,law,1,library,1,life,99,life cycle,2,lifehack,10,literature,1,literature review,1,logistics,2,luxury,1,making,4,management,9,manufacturing,4,material culture,4,materials,4,mechanics,1,media,9,method,45,migration,1,mobile,1,motion design,1,movie,2,multimedia,1,nature,1,new product development,5,Nexus 6,1,olfaction,1,online,1,open design,1,organization,1,packaging,1,paper,17,participatory design,9,PBL,1,pengate,1,performance,1,PhD,24,philosophy,44,planning,2,policy,6,politics,44,practice,13,predatory,3,preservation,2,prison,1,proceedings,1,productivity,103,project management,1,public space,6,publishing,3,reading,1,Remember The Milk,1,reproduction,1,research,80,research through design,1,resource-limited design,1,reuse,1,review,72,Samsung,3,scholarship,43,science,46,science fiction,3,semiotics,4,senses,1,service design,12,simplicity,5,society,106,sociology,4,software,61,space,3,strategic design,2,student,8,sustainability,39,systems,48,tactile,1,tangibility,1,technology,16,textile,2,theatre,3,theory,6,Toodledo,2,Toronto,2,tourism,1,traffic,1,transhumanism,1,transnationalism,1,transportation,3,tv,1,uncertainty,1,universal design,3,urban,10,usa,8,usability,1,user experience,3,visualization,14,wearable,3,well-being,6,women,1,workshop,51,writing,2,
The Trouble with Normal...: Defining terms together: another data point
Defining terms together: another data point
The Trouble with Normal...
Loaded All Posts Not found any posts VIEW ALL Readmore Reply Cancel reply Delete By Home PAGES POSTS View All RECOMMENDED FOR YOU LABEL ARCHIVE SEARCH ALL POSTS Not found any post match with your request Back Home Sunday Monday Tuesday Wednesday Thursday Friday Saturday Sun Mon Tue Wed Thu Fri Sat January February March April May June July August September October November December Jan Feb Mar Apr May Jun Jul Aug Sep Oct Nov Dec just now 1 minute ago $$1$$ minutes ago 1 hour ago $$1$$ hours ago Yesterday $$1$$ days ago $$1$$ weeks ago more than 5 weeks ago Followers Follow THIS PREMIUM CONTENT IS LOCKED STEP 1: Share. STEP 2: Click the link you shared to unlock Copy All Code Select All Code All codes were copied to your clipboard Can not copy the codes / texts, please press [CTRL]+[C] (or CMD+C with Mac) to copy